Join Rob Birdsell and Kent Hickey as they dive into a thought-provoking episode with Brandon Jacobs, Search Consultant at Carney, Sandoe & Associates, as they explore the ever-evolving landscape of leadership in private and Catholic schools.

From rethinking traditional roles and expectations to embracing the humanity and imperfections of school leaders, this conversation challenges administrators to think outside the box when it comes to preparation and training. Brandon also shares insights into the value of partnering with executive search firms to find the right leaders, highlighting how this approach can elevate the process beyond what schools might achieve on their own.

Subscribe to our newsletter to receive monthly updates with the latest podcast release and blog posts related to K-12 Catholic education.

Key points discussed in the podcast

  1. Leadership Roles Are Evolving: School leaders today require a wider range of skills than in the past, including expertise in finance, advancement, and fundraising, in addition to pastoral care and spiritual guidance.

  2. Leadership Tenure Is Shortening: The average tenure for heads of school has dropped from 15–30 years to five–seven years, reflecting changes in the educational landscape and personal priorities.

  3. Adaptability Is Essential: Schools must match leaders to opportunities based on current needs, recognizing that not every leader is suited for every moment in a school’s evolution.

  4. Leadership Development Is Critical: There is a growing emphasis on preparing future leaders by exposing them to the realities of school leadership and helping them build the necessary skill sets.

  5. Succession Planning Is Often Lacking: Many schools do not have clear plans or ready candidates to step into leadership roles, leading to interim leaders and potential instability.

  6. Diverse Backgrounds in Leadership: More leaders are being drawn from outside education, bringing fresh perspectives and skill sets, which can benefit schools when coupled with strong educational leadership.

  7. Implicit Bias in Hiring: Search firms and school boards need to actively acknowledge and address implicit biases during the hiring process to ensure fair and thoughtful selection of candidates.

  8. Value of Search Firms: Partnering with search firms can help schools access broader networks, ask critical questions, and find leaders who are a better fit, especially during transitions.

  9. Importance of Interim Leadership: Interim leaders provide schools with the opportunity to reset and address cultural or operational issues before a permanent appointment, setting up new leaders for success.

  10. Teacher Shortage and Compensation: While the teacher shortage is less acute than during the pandemic, schools must address teachers’ economic and emotional needs, including respect, flexibility, and compensation, to retain and attract quality educators.